The Best Crossbow Broadheads for Deer

Best Crossbow Broadheads for Deer Hunting

Spread the love

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Disclosure of Material Connection: Some of the links in this post may be "affiliate links." This means if you click on the link and purchase an item, I will receive an affiliate commission. Disclosure in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission's 16 CF

If you are a hunter but do not want to deal with the hassle of owning a gun, a crossbow is likely the best choice for you. You will, however, need more items than just the crossbow and the arrow shafts. Finding the best crossbow broadheads for deer is essential for optimal hunting.

The broadheads are the actual piece of the arrow that pierces the target, not the arrow itself. It is helpful to think of them like an arrowhead, which is truly what they are. As with most things nowadays, though, they come in a variety of styles for every taste and in a variety of materials.

How to Choose the Best Crossbow Broadheads for Deer Hunting

The first thing to consider when choosing the best crossbow broadheads for deer is the type of game you intend on hunting. For instance, if you are mainly hunting small deer, a less substantial broadhead will do. If you intend on hunting large deer, elk, or moose, then look for more substance.

The next thing to consider is the type of crossbow you own. Some broadheads will likely be too heavy for a smaller crossbow, but that does not necessarily mean it will not work for deer hunting. Conversely, make sure the broadhead weighs enough for your bow too so as to avoid wobbles.

What to Look for in a Good Crossbow Broadhead for Deer Hunting

The first thing to look for in a good crossbow broadhead for deer hunting is stability. Some broadheads, mainly due to the weight or sometimes the design, cause your crossbow to veer off course. When hunting, you want to ensure your arrow flies true to the target you are aiming for.

The second thing to look for in a good crossbow broadhead for deer is strength and toughness. Killing a deer is not an easy task, so it is important to choose a broadhead that can do the job cleanly and in one go. Aiming is crucial, but so is a durable and strong broadhead to do the work.

Best Crossbow Broadheads for Deer Hunting

Huntingdoor 12-Pack 3 Fixed Blade Archery Broadheads

The Huntingdoor 12-Pack 3 Fixed Blade Archery Broadheads are a great, affordable choice for a fixed blade option. Their construction is durable and strong due to their solid design. Also, they are made from sturdy metal to make them capable of holding up to impact even after several uses.

One major benefit of these broadheads is that they are very affordable, especially for a 12-pack. This means you can easily purchase extras to have on hand for when you are out hunting. Even though they are cheap, they still pack a punch when aimed and shot correctly.

Though they have many good qualities, the Huntingdoor 12-Pack 3 Fixed Blade Archery Broadheads have their own setbacks too. For instance, they do not work well with high-powered crossbows and are more suited for longbows. In some cases, they actually come loose and fall off in flight.

Another potential issue is the small cut diameter (which is the hole they leave in the animal). With a small cut diameter, it is possible to nick the intended target without mortally wounding the deer. This can be frustrating to the hunter and downright cruel to the injured, yet alive, deer.


  • Flies straight to the target
  • Best used for compound bows and long arrows
  • Works well for small game hunting
  • Great value for money


  • Edges lack sharpness
  • Looks cheaply made


Aiskaer 18-Pack 125 Grain 3 Fixed Blade Hunting Broadheads

The Aiskaer 18-Pack 125 Grain 3 Fixed Black Hunting Broadheads are also a good option for deer hunting at a slightly higher price point than the first one. These broadheads are also constructed from all metal and are very durable, sturdy, and strong.

The blades on these broadheads really shine, which is what sets them apart from the other choices. They are very sharp, and they fly true to the intended target to produce the most impact. These two features also increase the cut diameter, making a one-hit kill more likely regardless of location.

Unfortunately, the Aiskaer 18-Pack 125 Grain 3 Fixed Blade Hunting Broadheads do have their drawbacks as well. For one, though the materials used will lead you to believe that they are durable, they likely cannot be used for more than one kill. The blades are simply not attached strongly enough.

Another issue with these broadheads is that, like the previous option, they do not work as well with heavier duty crossbows. Though they are made durably, a heavily weighed crossbow will likely overpower them, causing a wobbly flight. Hunting deer is about the limit as far as game size goes.


  • Incredibly sharp blades
  • Does not wiggle
  • Great for target practice and hunting
  • Good deal


  • Not packaged well
  • Not that strong; busted on impact


Dead Ringer Trauma Bow/Crossbow Broadheads

The Dead Ringer Trauma Bow/Crossbow Broadheads have a totally unique design from the first two options on this list. Rather than fixed blades, they use a more complex mechanical, variable blade. This design makes them a bit more expensive than the first two choices on the list.

One of the main draws of mechanical broadheads is an increased cut diameter. Mechanical broadheads fly like a bullet and then spring open upon impact, increasing the wound size pretty drastically. These blades, in particular, leave a diameter of two and a half to over three inches.

With more complex designs, however, there are more things that can go wrong in the hunting process. For instance, the blades on the Dead Ringer Trauma Bow/Crossbow Broadheads can break if the crossbow power is too much for them. This is unfortunate while out on hunting day.

Another disadvantage to this broadhead is that they are quite a bit more expensive per unit than the previous two options. Although they are reusable, unlike the other two options, the price tag is steep, especially for casual hunters. Plus, they only come in a three pack, which is rather small.


  • Looks pretty well-built
  • Unique and advance mechanical design
  • Flies true to the target


  • Only comes in packs of three
  • Expensive

Final Words

Much of the decision when it comes to choosing the best crossbow broadheads for deer hunting boils down to personal preference and needs. If you plan on only hunting deer, then a less pricey option will likely be the best. The first two options on this list will suit your needs well.

If you do need something a bit more durable and for a more serious, frequent deer hunting, the third option on this list is perfect. They can take a heavier beating, but they do cost a bit more. Ultimately, the best crossbow broadheads for deer hunting are out there for everyone’s needs.

About the Author Pink Crossbow

Jen loves the outdoors and enjoys exploring a wide-range of activities. A mother of 3 whose seen far too many friends suffer from cancer, she believes Pink Crossbow reflects a sport for LIFE. It's a reminder that archery belongs to everyone regardless of age, size, or gender...and real enthusiasts aren't afraid to wear pink!

Leave a Comment: